Conrad invited Nicole, Red Sox girl, over to the house. Our house. I couldn’t believe Red Sox girl was at our house. It was bizarre to have a girl there other than me.
It was midafternoon. I was out on the deck, sitting at the patio table, eating a Doritos sandwich when they drove up. She was wearing short shorts and a white T-shirt, and a pair of sunglasses on top of her head. The Red Sox hat was nowhere in sight. She looked chic. She looked like she belonged. Unlike me, in my old Cuz Beach shirt that doubled as a pajama dress. I thought he’d at least bring her inside the house, but they hung out on the other side of the deck, lying on the lounge chairs. I couldn’t hear what they were saying, but I could hear her giggling like crazy.
After about five minutes I couldn’t take it anymore. I got on the phone and called Cam. He said he’d be over in half an hour, but it was more like fifteen minutes.
They walked back into the house when Cam and I were arguing over which movie to watch. “What are you guys gonna watch?” Conrad asked, sitting on the couch opposite us. Red Sox girl sat next to him. She was practically in his lap.
I didn’t look at him when I said, “We’re trying to decide.” Emphasis on the “we’re.”
“Can we watch too?” Conrad asked. “You guys know Nicole, right?”
So, suddenly Conrad felt like being social when he’d spent the whole summer locked up in his room?
“Hey,” she said in a bored tone.
“Hey,” I said, matching her tone as best I could.
“Hey, Nicole,” Cam said. I wanted to tell him not to be so friendly, but I knew he wouldn’t have listened anyway. “I want to watch Reservoir Dogs, but Belly wants to watch Titanic.”
“Seriously?” the girl said, and Conrad laughed.
“Belly loves Titanic,” he said mockingly.
“I loved it when I was, like, nine,” I said. “I want to watch right now so I can laugh at it, for your information.”
I was as cool as a cucumber. I wasn’t going to let him goad me in front of Cam again. And actually, I still loved Titanic. What wasn’t to love about a doomed romance on a doomed ship? I knew for a fact that Conrad had liked it too, even though he’d pretended not to.
“I vote for Reservoir Dogs,” Nicole said, examining her fingernails.
Did she even get a vote? What was she doing there anyway?
“Two votes for Reservoir Dogs,” Cam said. “What about you, Conrad?”
“I think I’ll vote for Titanic,” he said blandly. “Reservoir Dogs sucks even harder than Titanic. It’s overrated.”
I narrowed my eyes at him. “You know what? I think I’ll change my vote to Reservoir Dogs. So it looks like you’re outnumbered, Conrad,” I said.
Nicole looked up from her fingernails and said, “Well, then, I change my vote to Titanic.”
“Who are you?” I muttered under my breath. “Does she even get voting privileges here?”
“Does he?” Conrad jerked his elbow at Cam, who looked startled. “Just kidding, man.”
“Let’s just watch Titanic,” Cam said, taking the DVD out of its case.
We sat and watched stiffly. Everyone else busted up laughing at the part when Jack stands at the helm and says, “I’m the king of the world.” I was silent. About midway through, Nicole whispered something into Conrad’s ear, and the two of them stood up. “See you guys later,” Conrad said.
As soon as they were gone, I hissed, “They’re so disgusting. They probably went upstairs to go at it.”
“Go at it? Who says ‘go at it’?” Cam said, bemused.
“Shut up. Don’t you think she was gross?”
“Gross? No. I think she’s cute. A little too much bronzer, maybe.”
I laughed in spite of myself. “Bronzer? What do you know about bronzer?”
“I have an older sister, remember,” he said, smiling self-consciously. “She likes makeup. We share a bathroom.”
I didn’t remember Cam saying he had a sister.
“Well, anyway, she does wear too much bronzer. She’s bright orange! I wonder where her Red Sox hat is,” I mused.
Cam picked up the remote control and paused the movie. “Why are you so obsessed with her?”
“I’m not obsessed with her. Why would I be obsessed with her? She has no personality. She’s like one of those pod people. She looks at Conrad like he’s God.” I knew he was judging me for being so mean, but I couldn’t stop talking.
He looked at me like he wanted to say something, but he didn’t. Instead he turned the movie back on.
We sat there on the couch and finished watching the movie in silence. Toward the end I heard Conrad’s voice on the stairs, and without even thinking I snuggled closer to Cam. I rested my head on his shoulder.
Conrad and Nicole came back downstairs, and Conrad looked at the two of us for a second before saying, “Tell my mom I took Nicole home.”
I barely looked up. “Okay.”
As soon as they were gone, Cam sat straight up, and I did too. He took a breath. “Did you invite me over here to make him jealous?”
“Who?” I said.
“You know who. Conrad.”
I could feel a flush rising up my chest and all the way to my cheeks. “No.” It seemed like everybody was wanting to know where things stood with Conrad and me.
“Do you still like him?”
“No.”
He let out a breath of air. “See, you hesitated.”
“No, I didn’t!”
Did I? Had I? I was sure I hadn’t. To Cam I said, “When I look at Conrad, all I feel is disgust.”
I could tell he didn’t believe it. I didn’t either. Because the truth was, when I looked at Conrad, all I felt was a yearning that never went away. It was the same as it had always been. Here I had this really great guy who actually liked me, and deep down inside I was still hung up on Conrad. There, that was the real truth. I had never really let go. I was just like Rose on that stupid makeshift raft.
Cam cleared his throat and said, “You’re leaving soon. Do you want to keep in touch?”
I hadn’t thought about that. He was right, the summer was almost over. Pretty soon I would be home again. “Um… do you?”
“Well, yeah. I do.”
He looked at me like he was expecting something, and I couldn’t figure out what it was for a few seconds. Then I said, “Me too. I do too.” But it came too late. Cam took his cell phone out of his pocket and said he’d better get going. I didn’t argue.
